Ventura County Insurance Market — What Landlords Face Right Now
Ventura County has experienced two of California's most significant wildfire events in a span of eleven months. The Thomas Fire in December 2017 burned 281,893 acres across Ventura and Santa Barbara counties — at the time the largest wildfire in California recorded history — killing two people and destroying over 1,000 structures. Less than a year later, the Woolsey Fire in November 2018 tore through Thousand Oaks, Malibu, and Agoura Hills, killing three people and destroying over 1,500 structures across Ventura and Los Angeles counties. For Ventura County's insurance market, these two events created a before-and-after line. The carriers that remained after Thomas reassessed their entire Ventura County exposure following Woolsey, and significant non-renewal activity followed.
The result is a Ventura County market where admitted carrier options for most foothills, canyon, and wildland-interface rental properties have been severely constrained or eliminated. Many landlords were non-renewed in 2018 and 2019, placed their properties on the FAIR Plan, and have remained there ever since. The SB 824 moratorium — which prohibited non-renewals in areas affected by gubernatorially declared disaster areas — provided temporary protection but expired January 7, 2026. Landlords who relied on that moratorium protection should be actively reviewing their situation now that it has lapsed.
The critical problem facing Ventura County landlords on the FAIR Plan is not the premium — though the FAIR Plan's approved 29.1% rate increase effective October 2026 makes that increasingly significant — it is the coverage structure. The FAIR Plan is a fire insurance policy. It does not provide landlord liability protection if a tenant or visitor is injured on the property. It does not provide loss of rents if the property is uninhabitable after a covered fire. It does not cover water damage, theft, vandalism, or any other cause of loss besides fire. A landlord who is on FAIR Plan without a Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy to fill those gaps is carrying dramatically less protection than they likely believe.
Not all of Ventura County is equally constrained. Coastal properties in the city of Ventura, Oxnard, and Port Hueneme generally retain better private market access — their wildfire risk scores are lower, and some admitted carriers continue to write there. Surplus lines carriers have stepped into the market for higher-risk placements, and while they are not subject to the same regulatory protections as admitted carriers, they provide genuine broad-form coverage including liability and loss of rents that the FAIR Plan cannot match. For most Ventura County landlords in wildfire-affected areas, the goal is a complete coverage program — whether through surplus lines alone or FAIR Plan plus DIC — that addresses the full range of landlord risks, not just fire.
Ventura County landlord on the FAIR Plan? Let's review what you actually have — and fix the gaps. Schedule a free review →